Some of it is sound (train, work hard, stop making excuses) and much of it isn't: research and official data contradict popular claims that depression isn't real, that degrees are worthless, that day trading is a way out, or that women only want money. Pick or paste a claim below to see what the evidence says, with sources, then run the seven-question test on whoever you're listening to.
Last updated:
Run it on anyone whose advice you follow. 2 = clean, 1 = unclear, 0 = fails.
Each claim is checked against peer-reviewed research or official statistics, and given one of four verdicts: False, Not supported, Misleading (true in a narrow sense, wrong as advice) or Partly true. Every card says what's worth keeping, because most of this advice works by wrapping a real need (purpose, money, respect, discipline) around a claim that doesn't hold.
The guru test comes from Why You Shouldn't Listen to Andrew Tate: seven questions scored 0 to 2. Under 9 out of 14, treat the person as entertainment, not instruction. The one-line version: take advice on X only from people whose results in X came from doing X, not from selling courses about X.
This tool checks claims, not people. It doesn't attribute any claim to any named person, and it doesn't make claims about anyone's legal situation.
This tool puts a few of the named techniques from Why You Shouldn't Listen to Andrew Tate to work. Each line says how it relates to the tool.
See every technique in Why You Shouldn't Listen to Andrew Tate →
Depression is real. The World Health Organization describes it as a common mental disorder, different from usual mood swings, and effective treatments exist, including talking therapies and medication. Exercise, sleep and routine help, and if low mood lasts more than a couple of weeks, the strong move is to talk to a doctor.
On average, no: US data show people with a bachelor's degree earn more and are unemployed less often than those with only a high-school diploma. But returns vary widely by subject and institution, and the IFS estimated that about one in five UK students would have been financially better off not going. Choose a course on evidence of outcomes, or pick a trade or apprenticeship.
Very rarely. A study of everyone who day-traded Brazilian equity futures for at least 300 days found 97% lost money, and only 0.4% earned more than a bank teller's wage. Long-term, low-cost investing and building a skill people pay for are far more reliable.
Research doesn't support that. In David Buss's study of about 10,000 people in 37 cultures, both women and men ranked mutual attraction, dependable character, emotional stability and a pleasant disposition near the top. Women did, on average, value good financial prospects more than men did, but well below those traits.
Mostly on outdated science. The famous "alpha wolf" came from studies of unrelated wolves in captivity; wolf biologist L. David Mech showed that wild packs are mostly families led by the parents. In humans, research finds people gain influence through dominance and also through prestige: skill, knowledge and being respected.
Ask how they actually made their money, whether their theory could ever be proved wrong, who pays for their reach, how they treat critics, whether they ever say "I'm not sure", what they said when they thought nobody was watching, and whether you'd defend their values to someone you love. Score each 0 to 2; under 9 out of 14, treat them as entertainment, not instruction.
Educational commentary on common claims, not medical, financial, legal or psychological advice. If you're struggling with your mental health, talk to a doctor; if you're in crisis or might harm yourself, call your local emergency number now. The book this links to is commentary on one public figure's own statements and the public record; criminal matters are described as allegations, which he denies, and he has not been convicted of any crime.